| A2. What do we already
know about Global Warming?
A brainstorm to find out what students already know about global warming,
to uncover misconceptions, and to discuss what needs to be learned in order
to understand the issue.
|
| New!
Video Discussion
Students view and discuss "Earth in the Hot Seat", a Bill Kurtis A&E
video documentary which presents the critical issues, evidence, and uncertainties
of the global warming debate.
Student handout: Discussion
Questions
(You can purchase the
video from A&E online, or by calling 888-423-1212. Cost:
$19.95, item #AAE-17591)
|
Revised!
Investigation Guide: Introduction
The Different Sides of the Debate & Project Overview
Use this resource throughout the entire project.
This packet can be used in a number of ways. It can be read as a class,
in groups, or for homework. It provides a narrative account of each stage
of the investigation so that students can break down the rather large issue
of global warming into smaller steps and understand why they are doing
each step. If possible, each student should get a copy of the entire packet,
which will be used at the start of each of the project’s three parts, and
should be encouraged to revisit it often. At this point of the project,
use the section entitled "Introduction to the Global Warming Issue". Save
the remaining parts for use at the start of sections 1, 2, and 3.
About the Introductory stage.
The first part of the introduction is a one page description of the
different positions that scientists and policy-makers take on the global
warming debate. It can lead to role plays, discussions, etc. The main goal
is to give students a view of the range of opinions surrounding global
warming and understand how complex the debate really is.
The second part is an overview of the entire global warming investigation.
You may wish to read it with students, use it to set milestones, or you
can have students create a similar list of steps on their own by asking,
"If we are going to learn how humans might be affecting climate, what do
we need to know and how might we go about learning it?"
Optional A5. Assigning roles: Becoming
scientific advisors and creating country profiles
In this activity, students are divided into teams
that advise individual nations about the global warming issue. Next, students
receive their “mission” from a joint committee made up of the heads of
these nations. Here they also learn about the competing viewpoints in the
global warming debate and why it is so difficult to prove that climate
is actually changing as a result of human activities. Students also begin
to learn about the countries they will be advising by doing research and
assembling profiles. This activity serves as a launching point for the
project and motivates the next section of activities.
Optional. Letters from the Secretary General of the "League of
Nations"
These letters are designed "hooks" to introduce
each phase of the project. They provide an ongoing narrative summary,
in the form of mission letters from the head of the League of nations,
which help to connect the tasks in each phase of the project with the larger
purpose of why they are important to understanding and explaining global
climate change. Specifically, they help students understand their
roles as "scientific advisors" to different nations of the world.
They can be used in addition to or instead of the above investigation guide.
Use each letter at the start of each phase of the project
Letter for Part 1: Student
version Teacher version
Letter for Part 2: Student
version Teacher version
Letter for Part 3: Student
version
|
| New!
Cause or Coincidence: What is the relationship between carbon dioxide in
the atmosphere and global temperatures?
This activity is an introduction to the relationship between carbon
dioxide (CO2) and temperature.
Evidence shows that both global temperatures and CO2 levels
in the atmosphere have increased significantly over the last 100 years.
The question is, are these increases linked to each other or merely coincidental?
Many scientists claim that this data provides evidence that humans,
by releasing CO2 into the atmosphere, are causing global temperatures
to increase. Other scientists point out that there is not enough data to
prove for certain that human actions?rather than natural processes?are
actually causing global temperatures to rise. They believe that the increases
are coincidental. The fact is, no one knows for sure.
This hotly debated question?Is a human-triggered increase in CO2
levels responsible for increased global temperatures or are these trends
merely coincidental?is the foundation for the rest of the investigation.
Graphs
Global mean temperatures,
1892-1999
Atmospheric CO2 concentrations, 1860-1990
Temperature and CO2 Levels for the
last 160,000 years
Storks and Babies: Does Correlation prove
cause & effect?
|
Revised! Investigation Guide: Part
1 (same investigation guide as above)
This is the next section of the Invesitgation guide introduced in
the previous section. This brief text gives students their mission
for this (the first) stage of the investigation, which is to understand
how temperature varies naturally. It explains that since temperature varies
naturally in may different ways and on many different time scales, we must
first understand these patterns in order to determine if humans are causing
temperature to vary "unnaturally" (i.e. causing global warming).
Optional Letter from the Secretary General of the
"League of Nations" (same as letters provided above)
A narrative introduction to Part 1 designed to
introduce roles and tasks and motivate students
|
B1. What
is temperature?
Measuring temperature in different parts of the school
This activity introduces students to the notion of temperature variation,
a fundamental concept in understanding global climate. By measuring temperatures
in different locations of the school and noticing that the results vary
significantly, students realize that there is no such thing as a "single"
temperature for a given area, but rather that temperature is constantly
changing and varies significantly by time and location.
Student handout:Blank data table
|
| Revised!
How does temperature vary over time?
Are current temperature increases natural or caused by human activity?
By looking at how temperatures vary naturally by day, by season, by year,
and over 500 and 10,000 cycles, students learn that temperature goes through
natural fluctuations all the time. Therefore, if we are to claim that current
temperatures are increasing due to human activities, we must first be able
to demonstrate that these increases are not part of a natural temperature
fluctuation. This activity helps us identify Earth’s natural temperature
fluctuations.
Student handouts:
Hourly temperature dataset
Blank Graph (hourly temp)
Datasets: Daily, 10-day, Yearly, 9,500 years
Blank Graph (daily temp)
Teacher resource:Sample temperature graphs
|
B4. How
does temperature vary by location?
WorldWatcher Introduction: Making temperature maps
In this activity, students learn how to interpret data visualizations
and use the WorldWatcher software while exploring how temperature varies
by geographic location. By drawing their own temperature maps, students
come to appreciate the basic elements of WorldWatcher data visualizations:
how colors, units, and geographic placement on a map can tell a story about
events and phenomena?in this case, how temperatures vary across different
parts of the globe. In addition, students learn to use WorldWatcher’s drawing
tools and different ways of analyzing data visualizations.
Student handouts:
Blank map with key
Drawing temperature maps
|
Revised! Investigation Guide, Part 2
The the next section of the Invesitgation guide used in the
previous 2 phases of the project. This brief text gives students their
mission for this (the second) stage of the investigation, which is to learn
how the climate system works in order to understand what makes Earth warm.
It describes the three main factors that determine temperature: incoming
sunlight, the reflection and absorption of sunlight on Earth’s surface,
and the role that the atmosphere plays in absorbing energy. There
is an emphasis on the atmosphere, since it is the factor which humans have
the most control over (through the emissions of greenhouse gasses such
as carbon dioxide.
Note: If you plan to skip the Pen light lab (C3) in
the interest of time, then you may wish to either inform students that
you will not be investigating the role of incoming sunlight, or you might
conduct your own brief overview of how the angle at which sunlight reaches
Earth determines the intensity of that light (thus, the equator receives
the most direct sunlight and thus the most intense light and the most energy
per area, while the poles receive the most indirect sunlight and thus the
least intense light and least energy per area. See the lesson plan
for more teacher notes on this subject matter.
Optional. Letter from the Secretary General of
the "League of Nations" (letter provided above)
A narrative introduction to Part 2 designed to
introduce roles and tasks and motivate students
|
Introduction |
| C3. Pen Light Lab:
The sun's rays
This lab illustrates how light intensity from the sun varies based
on the angle at which it hits Earth’s surface. This is particularly important
to understanding why temperatures vary by latitude: the equator receives
direct sunlight, whereas the sunlight light reaches higher latitudes is
less direct. Less direct sunlight is less intense, explaining why higher
latitudes receive less incoming solar energy.
While this lab helps explain what makes Earth warm, it is considered
"optional" to our investigation of global warming because the Earth-Sun
relationship is not something human actions are likely to affect.
Teacher resources:Angle measurement
templates
Student handouts:Lab sheet
|
Sun |
| C4. WorldWatcher Activity:
Where does Earth's heat come from? (whole-class or in groups)
This WorldWatcher activity can be done in small groups at computers
or as a whole-class discussion using either transparencies or an LCD projector
attached to a computer. The purpose of this activity is to see that while
Earth receives consistent amounts of solar energy at each latitude (due
to the even spin of the globe on its access), surface temperatures do not
follow such an even pattern. By allowing students to compare visually the
uniformity of an incoming solar energy visualization (represented in even
bands of colors) to the lack of uniformity of surface temperature (choppy
bands of colors), students begin to consider other forces besides incoming
solar energy (such as weather systems, ground cover, the oceans, elevation,
and so on) which must be at work that determine the heat we feel on the
surface. This is a set-up for activities C5 & C6, which explores the
role of the surface in absorbing different amounts of energy.
Teacher resources:
Activity sheet (with notes)
Picture of Incoming Solar Energy WorldWatcher
Visualization
Picture of Surface Temperature WorldWatcher
Visualization
Student handouts:Activity sheet
|
Sun |
| C5. Reflectivity Lab:
Which colors absorb the most energy?
This lab explores how different colored surfaces
absorb and reflect different amounts of energy. By placing different colored
envelopes under a heat lamp and measuring their temperatures, students
learn that lighter colors tend to reflect light while darker colors tend
to absorb light (and thus retain more energy). This is important to understanding
what happens to sunlight when it reaches the earth.
Student handouts:Lab sheet
|
Surface |
| C6. WorldWatcher Activity:
What happens to sunlight on Earth?
Building on C5, this activity explores solar reflectivity
and absorption on a global scale. By exploring datasets which show the
reflectivity of the earth’s surface, students learn about how different
types of ground cover reflect and absorb different amounts of solar energy.
This helps to explain how different parts of the world interact with the
sun and how climate varies because of it.
Student handouts:Activity sheet
|
Surface |
| C9. Greenhouse Gas
Lab: Measuring the heat absorption of carbon dioxide
Carbon Dioxide is identified as "greenhouse gas"
because of its ability to trap heat within earth’s environment. This investigation
is designed to compare the ability of a sample of carbon dioxide gas to
absorb thermal energy compared to a sample of air. Through this experiment,
students will have the chance to build a visual representation of the greenhouse
effect by witnessing how carbon dioxide absorbs and retains heat more than
plain air. The experiment illustrates the heat-absorption of atmospheric
carbon dioxide. It is recommended that students read the handout explaining
"What are the greenhouse gasses."
Revision note: As a variation on
the existing lesson plan, measure the flasks of trapped carbon dioxide
and plain air during both their warm-up and cool-down phases. By adding
the measurement of the cool-down phase to the lab procedure, you will better
witness the role that CO2 plays in retaining energy.
Teacher resources:
Background reading: The Greenhouse
Effect and Global Warming
Background reading: What is the Greenhouse
Effect?
Background reading: What are the Greenhouse
Gasses?
Student handouts:
Lab sheet
Blank graph
|
Atmosphere |
| A3. Why is average
temperature greater on Venus than on Mercury?
This activity is designed to demonstrate the effects of that atmosphere
plays in maintaining temperature (known as the "greenhouse effect"). Students
compare Venus, which has a thick atmosphere and fairly consistent day and
night temperatures and Mercury, which has no atmosphere and temperatures
ranging from very hot during the day to very cold at night. This comparison
is a clear illustration of the role that atmospheric gasses (such as H2O
and CO2) play in warming planets.
Teacher resources:
venus picture
mercury picture
|
Atmosphere |
| C8. WorldWatcher Activity:
What would temperature on Earth be without the greenhouse effect?
This activity, designed for shock effect, shows
students what temperature on earth would be like without the greenhouse
effect. Targeting a common misunderstanding that the sun is mostly responsible
for maintaining comfortable surface temperatures, students see a chilling
dataset (both literally and figuratively!) showing the surface temperature
that results solely from the energy absorbed from the sun. Realizing that
this is not enough energy to sustain life on earth, students are left to
wonder what other factors contribute to the temperatures we are used to
(e.g., the greenhouse effect).
Teacher resources:
Background reading: Is the Greenhouse
Effect Good or Bad?
Student handouts:
Activity Sheet
|
Atmosphere |
| New! Carbon Cycle Activity
This is an online
activity investigating the carbon cycle (as well as an optional activity
on the water cycle) are available at:
http://www.letus.northwestern.edu/projects/gw/cycles.html
The activity sheet is provided in this packet, but you
will need to go online to experience the activity.
In a previous activity, we noticed that carbon dioxide
concentrations have increased over the past 100 years to levels never seen
before. But where does this carbon dioxide come from? The fact is, Earth
has always contained more or less the same amount of carbon molecules.
Therefore, we know that the carbon now in the atmosphere had to exist somewhere
on Earth before becoming a greenhouse gas, but where?
In this activity you’ll have the chance to investigate
many of the ways in which carbon travels throughout earth ecosystems. This
will be done by following one carbon molecule, "Carbo", through what we
call the carbon cycle.
|
Atmosphere |
D3. WorldWatcher Activity:
Investigating population and carbon emissions
In this activity, students look at a carbon emissions dataset to see
which nations emit the most carbon per year. They then compare this to
a dataset of population density, noting which areas have the densest populations
as compared to the areas which emit the most carbon. Students learn that
while many countries emit large amounts of carbon per year, some of these
countries (such as China & India) have dense populations while others
(such as the United States) have sparse populations. This leads to discussion
of the difference between "total carbon" emissions versus "carbon per person".
As a result, students learn which countries pollute the most per capita.
Optionally, students examine an additional visualization that shows
carbon emissions divided by population density to see directly which countries
emit the most pollution per person.
Student handouts:
Activity sheet (option A): Investigating
Population & Carbon Emissions
Activity sheet (option B): Investigating Population
& Carbon Emissions
Carbon emissions by country graphs
Carbon emissions by country worksheet
|
Atmosphere |
| New. Supplemental
Resource: Sources of Carbon Dioxide
In this "pie chart" shows the different sources of human-made carbon
dioxide and provides some important facts about these sources. It is intended
as a supplement to the previous activity.
Resource: Sources of Carbon Emissions
|
Atmosphere |
| Revised! Investigation Guide, Part 3.
This final section of the guide (see previous phases of the project)
gives students their mission for this (the third) stage of the investigation,
which is to determine how climate change might affect different regions
of the world and to develop scientifically supported solutions which might
reduce the likelihood that human activities will bring about climate change.
This stage of the project involves a greater degree of independent work
and is open to a wide range of adaptations and variations depending on
the nature of each classroom.
Optional Letter from the Secretary General of the
"League of Nations" (letter provided above)
A narrative introduction to Part 3 designed to introduce
roles and tasks and motivate students
|
| D2. WorldWatcher Activity:
Exploring a predicted global warming scenario using a climate model
In this activity, students explore visualizations that show predicted
temperatures and precipitation levels in 2030, based on a climate model.
The model is based on a 1% increase per year in carbon emissions. Students
explore how different parts of the world will be affected by the predicted
changes and discuss the potential impacts on humans.
Student handouts:
Map of the world with location labels
Activity sheet: Temperature
Activity sheet: Precipitation
Alternate activity sheet: Developing and Industrialized
nations: Temperature & Precipitation
|
| D4. WorldWatcher Activity:
Using data to investigate issues
In this activity, students explore the specific issues that global
warming poses to their individual countries and begin to think about some
possible solutions to these issues. Using WorldWatcher datasets, students
investigate issues such as coastal population, deforestation, and emissions
in order to gather information related to the global warming issue. This
is an evidence-gathering activity that should be integrated with planning
for final presentations.
|
| D5. Finding solutions
to the global warming issue
In this activity students look at a list of solutions taken from the
recent global climate conference in Kyoto and discuss ways that they could
justify these solutions with scientific evidence. If possible, they use
WorldWatcher or other data to justify a few solutions of their choosing.
They then draft recommendations to the head of state of their country outlining
possible solutions and evidence that supports how they would work.
Student handouts:
Proposed global warming solutions (Kyoto
treaty articles)
|
| D6. Final Presentation:
Proposals to Heads of State
Students present and defend their solutions to the class and to any
outside visitors (perhaps representing diplomats of heads of state or the
U.N. Secretary General). They must draw upon scientific evidence to justify
their solutions (e.g., use the carbon cycle to explain why planting trees
will reduce atmospheric carbon dioxide).
If applicable, they also should be able to explain how their chosen
solution addresses the needs of a specific country or set of countries
(e.g. Brazil would favor a plan that gives emissions credits to nations
with large forests because of the role they play in removing carbon dioxide
from the atmosphere).
If time permits, students can debate the economic feasibility of their
plans (such as how they might impact jobs or costs of goods).
The aim of this activity, which can be extended over several days, is
for students to be able to argue and debate the issues they have spent
so long investigating, placing them into a global political and economic
context.
|